The Boys Club, and Only the Boys Club

The Boys Club, and Only the Boys Club

What happened next?

When we last met Ms. Exceptional in my previously released article *The Honeymoon Is Over*, the question was whether her organization, and especially her direct manager, could handle a truly outstanding hire. The answer is now clear, and it’s uncomfortable: this was never about handling her. It was about something far more fragile.

This isn’t a small business with a nervous founder. It’s a very large, globally recognized corporation, a household name in its industry. (And, for the record, it’s not Microsoft.) If it can happen here, it can happen in your company, quietly, while the right people smile in the right meetings.

The Club under Stress

Every long-standing organization has a club: an informal circle that sworn-in members rely on to share the stakes, protect one another’s numbers, and advance one another’s careers. The accounts were distributed long before Ms. Exceptional arrived, and everyone in the arrangement was comfortable with it.

Then she joined and took on those accounts. All of them. Customers who hadn’t moved in three years suddenly began to move, and within six months they were on track to overachieve. Do the math as a board member would: same customers, same market, same product, new person, completely different result.

That’s the problem. The boys look bad now, and they know it. Questions will come, and from way above. Something must be done before they do.

The Dilemma: There is Nothing to Find

The easy way out is the oldest: find something, anything, and let her go. Performance, conduct, compliance. Done. Everyone relaxes again.

The problem is there is nothing to find. She wins deals, serves customers, and follows the rules. Too bad: that would have made it so simple.

The club cannot fire its way out of this, so it must think. That is not natural for it. They wanted an exceptional hire. They never expected her to be exceptionally exceptional. And she had already been seen high up the management chain, so a sudden, unexplained exit would raise exactly the questions they want to avoid.

The goal therefore changes. She must not be removed. She must leave on her own, so that the story told upward is one of regret: "We are very sorry to see her go, but in the end, she was not strong enough."

Plan A: Drown Her

The first tactic was to give her more than anyone could handle: five or more major enterprise accounts, enough work for three full-time employees. Surely, she would quit.

She quickly asked for help but was told she was winning too many deals and should slow down, in effect, let customers down. That was not in her nature, so she kept going and skipped the annual leave her colleagues and managers took to recover from the same workload.

When she asked for support again, they told her to delegate. A hire would come, but it would take time. Her manager said he had received over 50 applications, none of which were good enough, and asked her to hang on longer.

She did. Giving up was not in her makeup, a fact the club had overlooked. Plan A failed.

Plan B: Humiliate Her

Frustrated, the boys sat down again. None could devise a plan alone; they needed each other.

Their new idea was to strip her of her prestigious enterprise accounts, tell her she wasn’t good enough, and leave her visibly overwhelmed, even though she was doing three people’s work and winning customer after customer, which the club still couldn’t explain, and to send her to build a territory from scratch, one never considered a strategic priority. Out of sight, out of the way, everyone could relax.

The manager played messenger, presenting the plan and giving her time to consider it as if she had a choice. She quickly realized she didn’t: he had already reassigned the accounts and announced who owned the prestigious customers. It wasn’t her. The club members had divided them among themselves.

The result: they secured the stakes, others claimed the numbers she created, and the only person publicly worse off was the one who delivered.

This is not (only) a Gender Story

Don’t read this as a story about men and women. Any closed circle protects its own interests when threatened. This is about belonging, not gender.

Still, the playbook is crude: overload her, sideline her, then divide the spoils. Like-minded men accustomed to agreement can devise it quickly, and it shows. The plan is predictable, easy to document and see through, if anyone above is paying attention. A club that thinks alike also plans alike, creating its own risk.

As a leader, ask not who’s in the club, but whether anyone outside it has a voice.

The Psychological Sandwich

Ms. Exceptional is squeezed between two layers, and the pressure comes from both sides.

The top layer is the story told about her. She is told she is not good enough and overwhelmed, even though her numbers show the opposite. She is told to slow down, to let customers down, and to wait for help that never arrives. Praise and criticism arrive in the same week, and neither aligns with the facts. This is a classic double bind: whatever she does, she is wrong. If she works harder, she proves she can carry the load, so the load does not shrink. If she asks for help, she confirms she is overwhelmed.

The bottom layer is who she is. Her loyalty to customers, sense of responsibility, and refusal to give up are what made her exceptional in the first place. The club isn’t attacking her weaknesses; it’s exploiting her strengths. The very qualities that make her excellent are also what keep her from walking away or letting people down.

In the middle is the filling: Every exit looks like a loss. If she accepts the new territory, she is sidelined. If she refuses, she is labeled "not a team player." If she resigns, the club's narrative that she was not strong enough is confirmed. If she stays and absorbs everything, she becomes quiet proof that the tactic works.

A person in this position rarely makes good decisions in the moment. The next step must be chosen deliberately, and that is exactly what good coaching is for.

Three Coaching Questions for Ms. Exceptional

She must decide whether the demotion and personal humiliation of building a non-strategic territory from scratch are worth considering, or whether the club wins and she resigns. Three questions help her answer it on her own terms, not theirs.

Question 1: What do you want from your career, and does this company still offer it?

Intent: Break the reactive loop. After months of defending herself, she has stopped asking what she wants. This question puts her goal back at the center, ahead of the club's story.

 

Question 2: If this territory were offered to you on its merits, what would have to be true for it to be a real step up?

Intent: Test the offer, not the intent behind it. A genuine opportunity has a mandate, budget, executive sponsor, success criteria, a timeline, and fair compensation. If none of these exist, it is a parking lot with a new title.

 

Question 3: Who above the club already sees your results, and what is your best move that doesn't depend on the club's permission?

Intent: Move from victim to strategist. It surfaces sponsors, evidence, and alternatives, internal or external, so that any decision she makes is a choice and not an escape.

 

The answers determine the path. If the territory passes the second question, it could be a real chance to build something entirely hers, with the right support and visibility. If it fails, the question is no longer whether the club wins, but how she leaves: on her own terms, with her results documented and her next role chosen deliberately.

The boys win only if she leaves on their terms. She decides what the story is.

0 comments

Leave a comment